Not a top-four team: How rival recruiters really rate the Bulldogs’ list

1 week ago 6

The conception that the Western Bulldogs person a apical 4 database is disconnected the people according to 4 of the 5 nine database managers The Age asked to anonymously measure the Bulldogs’ database following their upset nonaccomplishment to Hawthorn.

Such judgments of the database are astatine the bosom of the galore outer assessments being made of Luke Beveridge’s show arsenic manager during 2024, arsenic nine president Kylie Watson-Wheeler told the ABC connected Monday “it was excessively aboriginal successful the play to panic oregon marque rash decisions”.

Marcus Bontempelli astir inspired his squad to triumph against the Hawks

Four of the 5 nine officials, speaking anonymously to marque honorable assessments of an absorption list, enactment the Bulldogs among the bracket of teams that could decorativeness anyplace from 5th to 13th, depending connected variables specified arsenic luck, wounded management, coaching, motivation, squad synergy, accomplishment execution and leadership.

Collingwood, Sydney, the Giants, Geelong, the Brisbane Lions, Melbourne and Port Adelaide are considered the main top-four chances this season.

One recruiter described the Bulldogs’ database illustration arsenic “confusing”, portion different said their defence was “wobbly”. A 3rd database manager said the Dogs’ database indisputably carries top-end endowment that is the envy of different clubs, but past it “just drops away”.

The 1 database manager impressed with what is astatine the Bulldogs’ disposal enactment their database “in the apical bracket due to the fact that of the fig of A-graders”.

The Western Bulldogs person Marcus Bontempelli, Aaron Naughton, Jamarra Ugle-Hagan, Bailey Smith, Tim English and, eventually, Sam Darcy successful that category.

They person a 2nd tier of players – immoderate premiership players, All-Australians, oregon some – who, portion inactive of AFL quality, are not astatine the highest of their careers. These players see Caleb Daniel, Jack Macrae, Jason Johannisen, Taylor Duryea, Bailey Dale and Tom Liberatore (who was outstanding before being concussed successful circular five) and players connected the up specified arsenic Ed Richards, Cody Weightman and Rhylee West.

The has nine re-signed Ugle-Hagan for 2 years and Naughton for nine, locking successful a two-pronged onslaught that is yet to lucifer the heights of Carlton’s guardant duo Charlie Curnow and Harry McKay. Once Ugle-Hagan’s declaration kicks successful adjacent season, that is the output they volition beryllium expected to conscionable arsenic they volition beryllium connected akin money.

Smith and English stay unsigned beyond this season, portion Bontempelli’s and Darcy’s contracts decorativeness astatine the extremity of 2025. Bontempelli offers much worth than immoderate declaration helium has ever signed, but determination is an acknowledgment helium needs others to stock his load portion English, last year’s All-Australian ruckman, is holding up his extremity of the bargain. However, clubs perpetually statement however overmuch TPP wealth should beryllium invested successful ruckmen.

The Bulldogs cognize determination are gaps, trading into the apical 10 successful past year’s draught to unafraid midfielder Ryley Sanders, having landed Ugle-Hagan and Darcy successful consecutive years successful 2020 and 2021 astatine prime 1 and prime 2 respectively arsenic a Next Generation Academy postgraduate and a father-son recruit.

They besides drafted gangly defender Jedd Busslinger successful the archetypal circular successful 2022. He is yet to play a elder lucifer but has been tenable successful the club’s undefeated VFL team.

With Rory Lobb and father-son Jordan Croft besides connected their list, 1 recruiter suggested the nine commercialized retired a prime tall, divided the prime and adhd velocity to what is – though damaging erstwhile they get connected apical of the absorption – a one-paced midfield.

Another recruiter agreed, saying galore of the talls run amended “when they are the main man” and wondered whether that was a crushed wherefore the large names weren’t functioning arsenic good arsenic their fans expected.

Losing Josh Dunkley to the Lions robbed the Bulldogs of their cardinal antiaircraft midfielder.

That recruiter said helium recovered the database “confusing”, with the summation of Lachie Bramble and Oskar Baker arsenic mature-aged players done the pre-season supplemental enactment process making “no sense”.

Even the recruiter who assessed the database arsenic A-Grade admitted that the bottommost six players selected successful the squad each week were not arsenic beardown arsenic those who played for different contenders.

One recruiter besides said the nonaccomplishment of Josh Dunkley to Brisbane and Patrick Lipinski to Collingwood – some of whom played successful past year’s expansive last – was a misstep the nine is yet to retrieve from, with Adam Treloar the lone subordinate traded successful since 2020 who has had an impact.

The club-wide reappraisal that saw large changes made to the coaching set-up underneath Beveridge was followed by the Peter Jackson review, which backed the manager portion recommending that the workload beryllium shared among shot section leaders with Matthew Egan being fixed an operational relation arsenic shot manager.

But a bounce is yet to occur.

Having missed finals past play aft losing 8 of their last 11 matches, the nine person won conscionable 3 of their archetypal 8 games to beryllium successful 11th spot. Seven of the 13 losses successful that play person been by a borderline of 7 points oregon fewer.

Although they bash not person a first-round prime this season, they would beryllium apt to summation 1 if the injured Smith departs, with Geelong and Hawthorn among his suitors. Gaining an aboriginal prime would beryllium handy, said 1 recruiter, arsenic it could beryllium divided and utilized to draught endowment successful what recruiters accidental is shaping arsenic an adjacent and heavy draft.

Watson-Wheeler said finals were the evident ambition astatine the commencement of the season, with the Dogs having finished ninth the twelvemonth before. They play Richmond this play earlier games against the Giants, Sydney and Collingwood.

“I deliberation that we are successful a spot of a signifier of improvement wrong the squad successful determining however we marque definite we present that precocious show that we person the quality to do,” Watson-Wheeler said.

Keep up to day with the champion AFL sum successful the country. Sign up for the Real Footy newsletter.