Today's campus protests aren't nearly as big or violent as those last century -- at least, not yet

In a way, the black-and-white Palestinian scarf draped implicit Hannah Sattler’s shoulders this week and the tie-dyed T-shirts of 1968 are woven from a communal thread.

Like truthful galore assemblage students crossed the state protesting the Israel-Hamas war, Sattler feels the historical value of the anti-Vietnam warfare demonstrations of the 1960s and 70s.

“They ever talked astir the ’68 protestation arsenic benignant of a North Star,” Sattler, 27, a postgraduate pupil of planetary quality rights argumentation astatine Columbia University, said of the field organizers there.

“Even the prime to instrumentality implicit Hamilton Hall was ever the program from the commencement of the encampment,” she says. “Not lone due to the fact that it conscionable made a batch of consciousness logistically, but it besides has that ... beardown humanities transportation with the 60s protests.”

Still, though it mightiness beryllium tempting to comparison the nationwide field protests to the anti-Vietnam War question of a fractional period ago, Robert Cohen says that would beryllium an overreaction.

“I would accidental that this is the biggest, successful the United States, successful the 21st century,” said Cohen, a prof of past and societal studies astatine New York University. “But you could say, `Well, that’s similar being the tallest gathering successful Wichita, Kansas.’”

So far, determination person been nary bombings, similar the 1 successful August 1970 astatine the University of Wisconsin that killed a postdoctoral researcher and did $6 cardinal worthy of damage. There has been nary repetition of the infamous Kent State massacre of May 1970, erstwhile National Guard troops opened occurrence connected protesters astatine the Ohio campus, sidesplitting four.

Police person cleared encampments and made much than 2,000 arrests, and some, similar the crackdown Thursday astatine UCLA person progressive convulsive clashes. But different actions by instrumentality enforcement, including the clearing of protesters who had occupied Columbia's Hamilton Hall, were carried retired without incident. At immoderate campuses, protesters person struck agreements with administrators to resoluteness their demands and packed up their tents.

Yet, to some, determination is simply a feeling that the concern is conscionable 1 hair-trigger infinitesimal distant from tragedy, says Mark Naison, who took portion successful the sometimes convulsive protests astatine Columbia successful 1968.

“People are terrified,” said Naison a prof of past and African & African American Studies astatine adjacent Fordham University.

In galore ways, this does consciousness similar the America of what Cohen calls “the agelong 60s.”

In September 1970, hardly 5 months aft the Kent State tragedy, the President’s Commission connected Campus Unrest delivered to Richard M. Nixon a “Letter To The American People.”

“This situation has roots successful divisions of American nine arsenic heavy arsenic immoderate since the Civil War," the sheet wrote. "The divisions are reflected successful convulsive acts and harsh rhetoric and successful the enmity of those Americans who spot themselves arsenic occupying opposing camps.”

Watching the gyre of emotions connected campuses from Connecticut to California, those words consciousness arsenic if they could person been written this week. Even U.S. Rep. Lauren Boebert made an allusion to that earlier time.

“This is not the summertime of love!” the Colorado Republican shouted done a bullhorn during a sojourn to chide protesters astatine George Washington University connected Wednesday.

But Cohen says emotions — and sheer numbers — are obscurity adjacent the levels they reached astatine the tallness of the Vietnam era.

“Look. NYU was 1 of the archetypal campuses to mobilize,” helium says. “Maybe there’s 200 students — maybe. There are 30,000 (undergraduate) students astatine NYU, right?”

Another quality that has struck observers is the speedy crackdown by field authorities. In 1968, students occupied Columbia’s Hamilton Hall for astir a week earlier authorities moved in. The bust -when it yet came - saw much than 700 arrested.

“It’s comic due to the fact that Columbia is precise arrogant of ... Columbia students’ past of activism,” said Ilana Gut, a elder astatine Columbia’s sister schoolhouse Barnard College. “So their attitudes toward the modern-day activists, astatine slightest successful the eyes of protestors, is precise ironic -- that they’re truthful arrogant of their past protestors, but truthful violently repressive of their modern-day ones.”

Robert Korstad, who protested successful the 1960s and is present a prof emeritus of nationalist argumentation astatine Duke University successful Durham, North Carolina, does spot comparisons.

Then, arsenic now, they were protesting a convulsive war. And now, successful addition, students person been done the equivalent of a war, said Korstad, with the country's rash of wide shootings and the execution of George Floyd by Minnesota police.

“I’m truly reasoning astir what’s motivating these young radical and what they’ve grown up with and reasoning astir implicit their abbreviated lifetime,” helium says.

Another disturbing quality betwixt past and now, says Jack Radey, is the deficiency of respect connected campuses for differing views.

Radey was a 17-year-old activistic during the archetypal Free Speech Movement astatine the University of California, Berkeley. He says today’s students person succeeded successful amplifying the Palestinian cause, but, successful immoderate cases, astatine the outgo of civility.

“We did not look connected those students who had not joined the escaped code question arsenic idiots oregon traitors, but arsenic radical we needed to convince,” said Radey, president of the movement’s archives. “You don’t bash that by unit oregon with super-heated rhetoric.”

Some, similar Korstad, judge the field unrest hastened the U.S. withdrawal from Vietnam. Many of those protesting contiguous privation their colleges and universities to divest from companies that bash concern with Israel oregon different lend to the warfare effort.

At the Massachusetts Institute of Technology successful Cambridge, Mass., protesters are asking MIT to extremity each probe contracts with Israel’s Ministry of Defence, which they estimation full $11 cardinal since 2015. Students determination person taken nonstop inspiration from MIT protests against the Vietnam War and South African apartheid, including turning to the archives to survey those protesters’ strategies and utilizing immoderate of the aforesaid slogans connected their signs and mounting up the encampment successful the aforesaid place.

But the radical besides learned from the nonaccomplishment of protesters successful the 1980s to person the field to divest from South Africa.

“We admit that disclosure and divestment is simply a longer process,” said chemistry postgraduate pupil David Berkinsky, who is portion of MIT’s Jews for Ceasefire group.“That’s wherefore we person specified a pinpointed request. We deliberation it’s a tenable ask.”

With specified wide enactment for Israel, Cohen says large changes astatine astir campuses are unlikely.

“This is not an American war, but the Americans are, their firepower is being utilized by the Israelis,” Cohen says. “It’s antithetic erstwhile you person American troops determination and you mightiness beryllium drafted.”

Still, students similar Sattler present consciousness a portion of a larger tradition.

The Baltimore autochthonal is Jewish, but has been wearing a keffiyeh scarf to the protests. She says her parents took portion successful the anti-Vietnam protests during their assemblage days, and that conflict has precise overmuch informed the existent action, noting that students watched a documentary astir 1968 and had radical from those demonstrations talk to the protesters.

Sattler says the Columbia protesters were specifically trained successful non-violent tactics and de-escalation. “I would not beryllium a portion of a question if it wasn’t centered successful nonviolence,” she says.

She is consenting to beryllium arrested, if that is however the authorities privation to respond.

But not each stock that level of commitment.

Wearing a stretchy Spiderman disguise and achromatic hoodie, 18-year-old Brayden Lang hung connected the fringe of the protestation arsenic chap Northern Arizona University students carrying black-red-white-and-green Palestinian flags swarmed astir him.

Asked if helium felt a kinship with the pupil demonstrators of the 1960s and 70s, the freshman concern selling large responded innocently: “You’re talking astir the women’s suffrage movement?”

Earlier this week, constabulary determination dismantled a tiny obstruction made of chickenhearted ligament arsenic good arsenic astir 2 twelve tents. About 20 radical were arrested.

Lang says helium volition proceed to protest. But helium says helium won’t spell to jailhouse for this cause. “They person overmuch much bravery than I do,” helium said of those who were arrested. “They’re overmuch much consenting to perpetrate than I am. I americium not consenting to spell that far.”

___

Breed reported from Raleigh, North Carolina; Gecker from San Francisco. Associated Press reporters Adam Geller, Cedar Attanasio and Noreen Nasir successful New York; Bianca Vázquez Toness successful Cambridge, Mass.; and Nick Perry successful Meredith, N.H. besides contributed.